Multitasking, the art of handling multiple tasks simultaneously, has become a fundamental aspect of daily life in our fast-paced society. It’s normal for us to divide our attention throughout the day, navigating a multitude of both routine and significant tasks, whether we’re answering work emails while watching TV, brainstorming shopping lists during meetings, or listening to podcasts while doing dishes.

Engaging in two things at once doesn’t always result in the same level of productivity or safety. The challenge with multitasking arises when tasks become intricate or require a substantial amount of energy, such as driving a car while talking on the phone. We tend to perform worse in one or both tasks in these situations.

In this article, you’ll discover why this occurs and how our multitasking skills evolve with age.

The Brain’s Executive Control

To multitask effectively, the brain’s executive control system, a neural network that orchestrates cognitive processes, must be activated. This system navigates the complex landscape of multitasking, which is predominantly associated with the prefrontal cortex. The prefrontal cortex, situated in the frontal part of the brain, plays a pivotal role in orchestrating the seamless integration of various cognitive functions.

One of the key features of the executive control system is its ability to shift attention dynamically. This involves the ability to swiftly redirect focus from one task to another, allowing individuals to adapt to changing demands and stimuli in their environment. Furthermore, our ability to structure and coordinate multiple tasks effectively depends on the executive control system.

In addition to attention, planning, and organization, the executive control system plays a central role in decision-making. It is the nexus where choices are evaluated, priorities are established, and actions are initiated. In the prefrontal cortex, executive functions work synergistically to harmonize the myriad components of multitasking.

The prefrontal cortex’s executive control system is not static; rather, it adapts and refines itself as it experiences and practices. The executive control system becomes adept at allocating cognitive resources optimally as individuals engage in diverse tasks. Individuals who have honed their multitasking skills through specialized training or regularly engage in complex activities exhibit this adaptability. Highly skilled individuals, such as experienced surgeons, demonstrate greater efficiency in handling multiple tasks simultaneously compared to less experienced counterparts. This suggests that highly automated skills and efficient brain processes contribute to enhanced flexibility in multitasking. In a busy operating suite, skilled surgeons can navigate complex procedures while managing additional cognitive demands.

The Young Brain and Multi-Tasking

Children, with their developing brains, face distinct challenges when it comes to multitasking. Both brain capacity and experience contribute to adults having a greater multitasking capacity compared to children. The maturation of the prefrontal cortex, responsible for sharing cognitive resources between tasks, plays a crucial role in reducing the costs associated with multitasking. However, children often experience a decline in walking speed and smoothness when engaged in cognitive tasks, highlighting the ongoing development of neural pathways during childhood and adolescence.

Brain Maturation and Multitasking Efficiency

The maturation of the brain, particularly the prefrontal cortex and the white matter tract connecting the hemispheres (corpus callosum), significantly influences multitasking efficiency. A larger prefrontal cortex enables better sharing of cognitive resources, allowing for improved performance in both motor and cognitive tasks. However, in children and adults with motor skill difficulties or developmental coordination disorders, multitasking errors are more common, emphasizing the intricate relationship between brain maturation and multitasking abilities.

Age-Related Changes

As individuals age, the neurobiology of multi-tasking undergoes subtle yet significant changes. Studies have shown that the prefrontal cortex experiences a gradual decline in volume and synaptic connections with age. This reduction in neural resources affects the brain’s ability to allocate attention and manage multiple tasks simultaneously.

Furthermore, the neurotransmitter systems crucial for executive functions, such as dopamine, may become less efficient, impacting motivation and sustained attention. The aging brain may struggle with task-switching, leading to slower cognitive processing and increased susceptibility to distractions.

Neuroscientific research indicates that older adults often experience challenges in filtering out irrelevant information, which can result in reduced efficiency during multitasking. This phenomenon is linked to changes in the connectivity between brain regions, affecting the coordination required for seamless task-switching.

Assessing multitasking capabilities becomes crucial, especially for older adults, as it can provide insights into the risk of future falls. Simple tests, such as walking while performing cognitive tasks, can help identify potential challenges and areas for improvement.

Interventions aimed at improving multitasking abilities in older adults include activities like pedaling an exercise bike or walking on a treadmill while engaging in cognitive tasks. The goal is to enhance the ability to divide attention efficiently, ignore distractions, and improve both speed and balance, promoting overall well-being in later years.

Compensatory Mechanisms

Despite these age-related changes, the brain remains remarkably adaptable. Older adults often develop compensatory mechanisms to mitigate the impact of cognitive decline. Neural plasticity allows the brain to reorganize and form new connections, potentially compensating for deficits in specific areas.

In addition, experience and expertise gained over the years may improve task performance in specific domains. Older individuals may leverage their accumulated knowledge and refined cognitive strategies to navigate complex tasks effectively, even if the raw speed of processing may be slower.

The Battle for Neural Pathways

The challenge with multi-tasking at a brain level lies in the competition for common neural pathways. When two tasks are performed simultaneously, they often contend for the same cognitive resources, akin to two intersecting streams of traffic on a road. This competition becomes more pronounced when tasks rely on shared sensory systems, such as vision, leading to increased interference.

Picture the brain as a bustling intersection where cognitive tasks represent distinct streams of traffic attempting to navigate through the neural network. As these streams intersect, the brain is faced with the demanding task of efficiently managing the flow of information. However, when two tasks contend for the same neural pathways, the result is a metaphorical traffic jam within the brain, causing interference and impeding the smooth progression of both tasks.

The intensity of this competition amplifies when tasks heavily rely on shared sensory systems, such as vision. In scenarios where the same visual pathways are crucial for the successful execution of both tasks, the interference reaches a crescendo. It’s akin to multiple lanes of traffic converging onto a narrow road, causing congestion and delays. In the neural realm, shared sensory systems become bottleneck points where cognitive traffic converges, leading to heightened competition and a subsequent decrease in the efficiency of processing both tasks.

This phenomenon sheds light on why multitasking becomes more challenging when tasks demand the simultaneous engagement of sensory resources. For instance, attempting to read a document on a computer screen while engaging in a phone conversation demands shared visual and auditory attention. As a result, the brain grapples with the dual demands, causing potential delays, lapses in attention, or errors in task performance.

Frontal Cortex and Cognitive Tasks

The brain’s planning centers in the frontal cortex play a crucial role in coordinating both motor and cognitive tasks. One of the key collaborators in this cognitive ensemble is the parieto-cerebellar system, which plays a pivotal role in coordinating motor movements and refining the precision of actions.

However when multiple tasks compete for the same sensory pathways, the frontal cortex faces a dilemma. The interference disrupts the natural flow of cognitive processes, hindering the brain’s ability to allocate resources efficiently. This disruption manifests as a slowdown in processing speed, a potential increase in errors, or even the prioritization of one task over another.

Real-world Implications

The impact of multitasking on neural resources becomes evident in everyday scenarios. For instance, engaging in tasks that compete for visual attention, like talking on the phone while driving, can be risky. The frontal cortex, responsible for planning and decision-making, struggles to allocate resources efficiently, leading to delayed reactions and an increased risk of missing critical signals, such as a sudden brake or a red light.

---

While the allure of multitasking persists, it’s important to recognize the emotional and energy costs associated with it especially when time-pressured. Many of us believe that multitasking saves time and energy in various aspects of life—be it at home, work, or school. However, the reality can be quite different.

Engaging in multitasking under time pressure often leads to heightened stress levels, triggering an increase in cortisol, the stress hormone. Prolonged exposure to such performance demands can leave individuals feeling fatigued and emotionally drained. The pursuit of efficiency through multitasking may inadvertently compromise overall well-being.